Award for bad academic writing
The worst sentences
Pouncing on the phrase "community standards," she declared that it entails -- as Crews summarized her position -- "a tendency to fall in line with social 'normativity' in general, especially as it applies to the imposing of heterosexist values and rules on people who should be left in peace to pursue their own goals and pleasures. Exactly what the prizes will be is uncertain the first three prizes were to be books , but something nice will be found. What's more, it raises questions about the purpose of scholarship. Without the jargon and ponderous content, he says, students quickly find themselves on the fast track to academic oblivion. As Sokal later wrote in the journal Lingua Franca: "Fair enough: anyone who believes the laws of physics are mere social conventions is invited to try transgressing those conventions from the windows of my apartment I live on the 21st floor ". Ordinary journalism, fiction, departmental memos, etc. It was located by M. Said himself is a progenitor of a new kind of literary and cultural criticism that has frequently used difficult language.
This is a mistake the authors of our prize-winning passages seem determined to avoid. The problem is not so much her lack of concern for clarity; it's her lack of concern for clarification. Dense, difficult writing is most often associated with newer academic fields like cultural studies, women's studies and ''queer theory.
But many academics have become so obsessed with cultural analysis, they've stopped writing about, or teaching about, the culture itself. She has been called one of the 10 most intelligent people on the planet by one academic, but the New Republic piece argued Butler's writings were virtually unintelligible.
In the limited range of options she offers us, Butler reveals much about the real politics behind bad academic writing. That these passages constitute bad writing is merely our opinion; it is arguable that anyone wanting to pursue an academic career should assiduously imitate such styles as are represented here.
Hexter and Mr. Said said that Fredric Jameson, a Duke professor who uses Marxist theory to study post-modernism and whose work has won the Bad Writing Contest twice, was ''in his way a poet'' whose writing, though difficult, has a cumulative brilliance.
In such a climate, the party leaders are insulated from all criticism. Sokal believed either editors would be so bamboozled by the mind-numbing rhetoric, or the editing would be so lacking in academic rigour that the piece's absurd thesis would go unchallenged.
But you can feel the strength of Butler's party even more strongly among those who support the Bad Writing Contest.
Bad writing examples
Since I'm not one of the 10 smartest people on the planet, I'm not sure. No longer defined by the common attachment to ordinary rational principles, our universities have become institutions of one-party rule. Together with the previous winners, it proves that was to bad prose what was to good music. Scorning Philosophy and Literature as "a small, culturally conservative academic journal," she aligned herself with "scholars on the left" who focus on "sexuality, race, nationalism, and the workings of capitalism. The reader may be baffled, but then any author who thinks visual experience is essentially pornographic suffers confusions no lessons in English composition are going to fix. Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 3. Nussbaum says scholars are sometimes encouraged to write in obscure language.
based on 8 review